• Featured
    • Bold arts and adventure icon
      Arts & Adventure
    • bold food drink and candlelight icon
      Food, Drinks & Candlelight
    • bold iconic outdoors icon
      Iconic Outdoors
    • bold offbeat and off the map icon
      Offbeat & Off The Map
    • bold romantic getaway icon
      Overnight Getaways
    • bold private spots icon
      Private Venues
    • Explore
    • Date Ideas
    • Blog
    • Suggest
    • Who & Why
    Sign in or Register
    Listing cover image

    Pressa Italia

    Italian Charm

    • Bookmark
    • See Photos
    • Profile
    • prev
    • next
    • Website
    • Directions
    • Share
    • Report
    • prev
    • next

    What makes it fun

    Pressa Italia is ready to sweep you off your feet, Italian style. From the moment you arrive, Pressa Italia feels like you’ve been whisked away to a cozy corner of the Italian countryside with charming farmhouse aesthetic, warm lighting, and an inviting patio surrounded by nature. The ambiance is effortlessly romantic. Pressa Italia serves up homemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and classic Italian dishes that make sharing practically mandatory. Pressa Italia hits that perfect sweet spot between elevated and cozy. It’s intimate enough for meaningful conversation, indulgent enough to feel special, and charming enough to make you both forget what time it is. Reservations are highly encouraged!

    Google Reviews

    Pressa Italia place picture
    Pressa Italia

    4.3

    Based on 610 reviews
    powered by

    Emily W. profile picture
    Emily W.

    2 weeks ago

    Loved this place. Best spaghetti and chicken Alfredo we have ever had. The staff were super attentive and friendly. The restaurant had a nice atmosphere as well, was perfect for a nice anniversary dinner.

    Alexandra F. profile picture
    Alexandra F.

    3 weeks ago

    We came here and ordered the lasagne, margarita pizza, steak and chocolate torte/olive oil cake for dessert. Food was delicious! Kimberly was our waitress and she was lovely and accommodating as we had kids with us. Will definitely be back next time we’re in the area!

    Vikas P. profile picture
    Vikas P.

    3 weeks ago

    Impressa… great food, nice service!!

    Madison C. profile picture
    Madison C.

    3 weeks ago

    Very delicious food & great service

    Fernando M. profile picture
    Fernando M.

    3 weeks ago

    Almost There! Well, I'm a bit torn on this review, but if I had to sum it up, I'd say: ALMOST THERE! My ratings for the performance and food quality are largely based on how the overall experience compares to the prices and my expectations. I understand this is a tourist area, so prices are naturally going to be marked up. However, charging for a side of bread at an Italian restaurant is a little diabolical... unless that bread is heavenly. Unfortunately, this was more like a dry version of Italian cornbread. The flavor was there, but the texture left something to be desired. My pasta was delicious, but it arrived a bit closer to room temperature than I would have liked. I could tell it had probably been sitting in the expo area for a little while because, once I mixed it, I noticed some warmth. I'm not necessarily someone who needs piping-hot food, but given the price point, I expect better attention to timing, presentation, and delivery. Considering how busy the restaurant was, our drinks also took a while to arrive. That said, we still enjoyed our experience overall. What really got me thinking, though, was the Parmesan cheese. I asked if we could get some, and we were brought the pre-grated kind that comes in bags and is portioned out for service. For a restaurant with this atmosphere, location, and price point, freshly grated Parmesan at the table would go a long way toward elevating the experience. Our server did his job and checked in on us, so I have no complaints about his attentiveness. However, the personalized service wasn't quite there. The experience felt more like interacting with an order taker than a server who was actively helping elevate the dining experience. By no means is this meant to be a complaint just for the sake of complaining. I genuinely see the potential here, and I hope ownership and management take this as constructive criticism and an opportunity to see the experience from a customer's perspective. My biggest recommendations? Work on timing, particularly with food and drinks, and revisit the quality of certain items, especially the bread. Small touches, like freshly grated Parmesan at the table, could also make a noticeable difference in how the experience feels relative to the price. Of course, I could be wrong about the bread. Maybe it's a local favorite! 😂 Overall, I think this place has potential. It's just not quite hitting the mark yet.

    Jerome W. profile picture
    Jerome W.

    2 months ago

    Wow! Such a nice restaurant! Pizza was the best I ever had!

    Adelena P. profile picture
    Adelena P.

    2 months ago

    If you’re wanting italian food go somewhere else. It was “okay” but $29 for a plate of spaghetti that is just lacking flavor and seasoning really sets the tone for the meal. Sadly there are just better experiences and food in Broken Bow.

    RV M. profile picture
    RV M.

    2 months ago

    Fancy! Excellent food!

    Neaci M. profile picture
    Neaci M.

    2 months ago

    Food was fantastic, flavorful, and amazing! Our server Desiree was magnificent and very knowledgeable, will definitely be back.

    Emma B. profile picture
    Emma B.

    2 months ago

    I’ve called no less than 10 times in the past two days and have left a message to have someone call me back with regards to our bill. There is a hidden mystery charge of $39 and no explanation. No line item. Nothing. Never have I ever dreamt that I needed to add up all of our purchases to make sure their system added correctly.

    Autumn S. profile picture
    Autumn S.

    2 months ago

    We had amazing service by Kimberly!! She was so sweet and attentive. The pepperoni pizza with hot honey was really good.

    Luke P. profile picture
    Luke P.

    2 months ago

    Mrs. Kim was the goat

    Andrew L. profile picture
    Andrew L.

    2 months ago

    Nothing. I could find said reservations were required. We tried to stop in and were turned away even though it was not that busy and there were plenty of empty tables for a party of 2. I have been to much better places who would be happy to seat anyone. Please go down the road to their competitor. Much better food, service, and prices.

    Noelle D. profile picture
    Noelle D.

    2 months ago

    Food was absolutely amazing and Brett was an amazing server! Highly recommend! Ask for Brett!

    Lindsey R. profile picture
    Lindsey R.

    2 months ago

    Kimberly and Colton were amazing! Made the bachelorette trip !! She deserves a raise! Atmosphere and food was also amazing!

    J. J profile picture
    J. J

    4 months ago

    The Pressa Italia is a wonderful restaurant. Everything we ate was delicious. The atmosphere and staff were both excellent. The most surprising dish for me was the key lime pie. It wasn't your typical key lime pie; it was more subtle and creamy, and it became my favorite.

    Timmy profile picture
    Timmy

    4 months ago

    Pressa has become our weekly go to. Menu is delish, wine is the best and Laisa is the best server there. Ask for her when you make your reservation! 5 stars all the way

    Kendra J. profile picture
    Kendra J.

    4 months ago

    I had the pleasure of being served by Laisa tonight . She was very attentive and accommodating. The food and atmosphere were great , I will definitely be returning!

    Jaynew L. profile picture
    Jaynew L.

    4 months ago

    Brett provided outstanding service from start to finish. He was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect without ever being overbearing. Our drinks stayed full, the food came out exactly as ordered, and he checked in at just the right times. His positive attitude and professionalism made the entire dining experience enjoyable. If you have the chance to be served by Brett, you’re in great hands. Highly recommend!

    Tracy T profile picture
    Tracy T

    4 months ago

    Visiting from Texas and do not recommend. Overpriced. Steak $55 and didn’t even come with a side. Other communication issues. Ordered bread with no cheese and it arrived with cheese. My son is allergic. My son told the waitress no cheese. Glad he didn’t bite into it and saw it underneath all of the stuff on the bread. Told the waitress we ordered it with no cheese and she said yeah it comes with cheese. 🤦‍♀️ They remade it. Ordered steak and it was raw. Had to be sent back twice. My son has his food management license and could do better. He’s also a great cook. If you don’t like lemon in your tea don’t order it as their teas, both sweet and unsweetened, are infused with lemon and it made me nauseous. Alfredo with chicken: the pasta was very dry so had to order more Alfredo sauce. The inside is nice but the visual aesthetics aren’t worth the price or the inconsistent service. We started to feel like we were a bother to staff because there were so many issues. Asked for sweet and low and was told they had it, then they bring me something that was green and NOT sweet and low.

    Wendy W. profile picture
    Wendy W.

    5 months ago

    Pressa Italia is such an incredibly charming and photogenic restaurant for the photos and vibes. Especially at 7 pm golden hour, the lighting is immaculate and makes the entire restaurant glow. Freshly picked flowers are such a nice addition to the tables. However, the food can be a bit underwhelming. The meatballs were fantastic, but my main entree of shrimp scampi was slightly bland and the noodles were fairly overcooked and soggy. Everyone else at my table seemed to enjoy their food, and it is one of our favorite restaurants that we've been at in Broken Bow, so I do recommend it, but perhaps choose another pasta or entree option. The drink options also appeared to be a little marked up for the amount that they provide, so be careful when ordering the things on the drink menu that don't have the price listed.

    Taylor H. profile picture
    Taylor H.

    5 months ago

    Pressa Italia was by far the best dining experience we had while in Broken Bow / Hochatown! When we arrived, we were greeted by a very friendly host and were promptly seated. My wife and I split the focaccia bread for our appetizer, then we both ordered the fettuccine alfredo for our entrees and it was amazing. We added a bottle of wine to go along with the meal and we are looking forward to coming back to Pressa in the future!

    Glory B. profile picture
    Glory B.

    6 months ago

    Kimberly was an excellent server! She made our experience top notch!

    Lara M. profile picture
    Lara M.

    6 months ago

    Food was absolutely delicious! Kimberly was our server and did a fantastic job! Atmosphere was exactly what we wanted. Will be back when here again!

    Jon T. profile picture
    Jon T.

    6 months ago

    Top notch service with even BETTER food.

    Jennifer M. profile picture
    Jennifer M.

    6 months ago

    Kimberly S was amazing service, great food!!!

    Abhija J. profile picture
    Abhija J.

    6 months ago

    We stopped at this Italian restaurant on our way back from Broken Bow. We ordered a Caesar salad and fettuccine pasta. I enjoyed the pasta, and it was flavorful. However, the Caesar salad was not suited to my palate. The staff were courteous, and our overall experience was good. Please note that the restaurant adds a 20% gratuity for large parties.

    Shari T. profile picture
    Shari T.

    6 months ago

    Our favorite dining experience in the area. Kimberly was great and gave excellent recommendations for both food and wine. I had the lasagna and he had the brussel sprouts and shrimp scampi. Don't miss out on the focaccia with garlic butter, it was so good.

    Jason S. profile picture
    Jason S.

    7 months ago

    Food and staff were amazing! Shout out to Brett, Jaden, and Kimberly for providing excellent, friendly customer service. Will definitely be going back.

    Rileigh G. profile picture
    Rileigh G.

    7 months ago

    We had an incredible experience celebrating my mom’s 60th birthday here! The staff truly went above and beyond the Manager Jennifer made her feel so special, and Kimberly took amazing care of our whole group. The food was absolutely outstanding, we’re still talking about it days later! Such a memorable evening. Highly recommend this place is a must-visit!

    K M. profile picture
    K M.

    7 months ago

    We had an incredible meal at Pressa Italia celebrating my birthday. The food was really good but what makes the whole experience is our server Kimberly. She’s so personable and pays attention to every detail. What a treat to have an exceptional server while enjoying the fun atmosphere and delicious meatballs and Brussel sprouts⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

    Emily J. profile picture
    Emily J.

    7 months ago

    New favorite place in Broken Bow! This whole atmosphere at this place is definitely elevated! All of the shops are so nice! The staff- one of the best I have encountered in a long time. Management down to every employee was over the top kind, helpful and made us feel like their personal guests. Can’t say enough positive about the staff! We had the charcuterie board which was great and the pizza with pepperoni, goat cheese and arugula with hot honey- PHENOMENAL!!!!

    Aubrey N. profile picture
    Aubrey N.

    7 months ago

    Came here after me & my Fiancé got engaged and it was amazing!! They were SO nice!! My Fiancé called ahead of time and told he was proposing to me before dinner and when we got there they had a whole table set up with a bottle of my favorite wine, a small flower arrangement and a hand written card signed by all the staff. It was the cutest thing ever and I loved it! Everyone was so sweet and the food was amazing and so was the atmosphere! I loved every minute of it!! 10/10 would recommend and we will definitely be back!!

    Latika S. profile picture
    Latika S.

    9 months ago

    We went to Pressa Italia for brunch and absolutely loved it, such an amazing spot. The vibe was super chic, the music was great and the food felt truly authentic. The highlight was the pasta, they even made a vegetarian version for us that wasn’t on the menu and it was incredible in both texture and taste. We also ordered a Caesar salad that was fresh and crispy, along with Brussels sprouts that were honestly finger-licking good. Everything was delicious. The place has great food and even the tap beer stood out, it had a subtle peachy note that made us wish we could take some home! Definitely a spot we’d love to visit again next time we’re in town.

    Eric L. profile picture
    Eric L.

    9 months ago

    We were pleasantly surprised to find such a fine dining experience with an authentic and homemade flavor. Lasia, our server was knowledgeable and helpful with the menu & she didn’t disappoint with her suggestions! We found our new favorite date night restaurant when we come back to visit. 10/10!

    Haley profile picture
    Haley

    11 months ago

    As somewhat of a foodie, this wasn’t the most flavorful food but it wasn’t bad. I think for the cost I expected it to be better but overall it was good. Especially since there doesn’t seem to be any incredible food in this city. 😅 I would recommend it to someone who is staying here and the pizza looked really good. Everything was plated very nice and great atmosphere. My feedback for the Alfredo is, the meat to pasta ratio was off, it needed more pasta and sauce but it did have a healthy portion of meat that was seasoned well and had a good crisp. The short rib ragu was good, not out of this world though. The bruschetta was the best thing we had, it was very good. 👍🏻

    Shawn H. profile picture
    Shawn H.

    12 months ago

    Fresh, excellent food with a great ambiance, and fantastic Limoncello! The salad dressing was amazing, the charcuterie board was so diverse and fresh, and the house made Limoncello was the best I've ever had. If they sold it by the bottle, I would have brought some home with me, but unfortunately they don't...I asked. Highly recommend! The manager came by and we talked for a bit. A younger guy from Fort Worth, but I can't remember his name right now. Well done sir. ***Update*** Went back in November...just as good. Phenomenal place. Our favorite Italian Food restaurant.

    Tags

    • bold food drink and candlelight icon
      Food, Drinks & Candlelight
    • bold happy hour icon
      Happy Hour
    • bold Italian food icon
      Italian Food
    • Lunch
    • bold outdoor seating icon
      Outdoor Seating
    • bold pizza icon
      Pizza
    • Bold Vegetarian options icon
      Vegetarian Options

    Location

    • 6427 N US Hwy 259, Broken Bow, OK 74728

      Get Directions

    Contact Information

    • Website
      https://www.pressaitalia.com/
    • Email Address
      natalie@crosslandinvestmentsllc.com

    You May Also Be Interested In

    Girls Gone Wine- Downtown

    • Fun Wines, Fun Times!
    $
    • bold food drink and candlelight icon
      Food, Drinks & Candlelight
    • +3 Outdoor Seating, Tasting Room, Wine Bar
    • Bookmark
    Gallery image

    Hachi Hachi

    • A Taste of Japan
    $
    • bold food drink and candlelight icon
      Food, Drinks & Candlelight
    • +7 Asian Food, Food Truck, Hibachi, Japanese Food, Lunch, Outdoor Seating, Vegetarian Options
    • Bookmark
    Gallery image

    The Tasting Room

    • Raise Your Glass to Romance
    $
    • bold food drink and candlelight icon
      Food, Drinks & Candlelight
    • +3 Bar, Cocktail Bar, Tasting Room
    • Bookmark

    Connect With Us

    • Info@RomanticSpots.com
    Facebook Twitter Instagram

    Daily Date Ideas

    ©2026 Romantic Spots LLC. (Romantic Spots) All Rights Reserved.

    • Privacy Policy

    Cart

      • Featured
      • Bold arts and adventure icon
        Arts & Adventure
      • bold food drink and candlelight icon
        Food, Drinks & Candlelight
      • bold iconic outdoors icon
        Iconic Outdoors
      • bold offbeat and off the map icon
        Offbeat & Off The Map
      • bold romantic getaway icon
        Overnight Getaways
      • bold private spots icon
        Private Venues
      • Facebook
      • X
      • WhatsApp
      • Viber
      • Telegram
      • LinkedIn
      • Tumblr
      • Reddit
      • VKontakte
      • Mail
      • Copy link
      • Share via...
      • Threads
      • Bluesky